Skip to content

Guides · 23 August 2026

A hydraulic cylinder losing force — five common causes

The machine runs slower than it used to, the cylinder will not reach the end of stroke, or it creeps down under load

A hydraulic press in the hall — the machine where a loss of cylinder force shows up
A hydraulic press in the hall — the machine where a loss of cylinder force shows up

Five common causes

Worn piston seal

Oil passes inside the cylinder between chambers instead of doing work. Typical symptom: the movement happens unloaded, but under weight the cylinder stalls or creeps down. Nothing leaks outside, which is why it gets mistaken for a pump fault.

Supply pressure too low

A worn pump, a relief valve out of adjustment or air in the circuit give exactly the same symptom as a worn cylinder. The cylinder is then perfectly sound and replacing it changes nothing.

Scored or corroded rod

A score on the working surface cuts the seal on every stroke. First you get dampness under the gland, then a leak, then a loss of force. The chrome is also frequently damaged by corrosion after the machine has stood.

Oval or scored bore

Contamination in the oil and running without proper lubrication wear the bore. The seal stops contacting all the way round, and oil bypasses the piston even after a new seal set.

Safety or load-holding valve

On cylinders with valves, a setting that has drifted or a contaminated seat lets oil past under load. The cylinder looks worn out although it only needs the valve reconditioned and calibrated.

What to check, in order

1

Measure the supply pressure

A gauge on the supply port, the cylinder under load. If the pressure does not reach its working value, keep looking at the pump and the relief valve — the cylinder is not the culprit.

2

Check the oil and the filter

Dark oil, a burnt smell or swarf on the filter explain both the worn seals and the scored bore at once. Replacing the cylinder without cleaning the circuit means doing it again in a few months.

3

Look at the rod fully extended

Extend it to the end of stroke and run a finger along the working surface. Scores, pitting and patches with no chrome settle it: a seal change alone will not be enough.

4

Look for a leak under the gland

Damp or a drop of oil on the extended rod means a worn sealing system. If it is dry outside and the force is missing, the leak is internal — at the piston.

5

Block the movement and watch for creep

Raise the load, close the supply and see whether the cylinder holds position. Slow creep with the supply closed points to internal leakage or to a valve, not to pump output.

6

Write the results down before stripping

The pressure you measured, the creep rate and the oil condition cut hours off the diagnosis in the workshop. The same data lets us assess the scope without seeing the machine.

An external leak versus internal leakage

External leak Internal leakage
What you see Oil under the cylinder, a damp rod Dry outside, but the force is gone
How the machine behaves Movement usually intact, tank level falling The cylinder stalls or creeps down under load
Most common cause Worn gland and rod seal Worn piston seal or a worn bore
What it usually takes New seals, often with rod machining Strip down, measure the bore, full seal set

How a cylinder can have pressure and no force

The force a cylinder produces comes from the pressure difference across the piston multiplied by the working area. When the piston seal stops separating the chambers properly, oil crosses to the other side instead of doing work. The gauge on the supply then reads correctly, the pump sounds normal, and the machine still will not pull. That is the most common story behind cylinders that arrive here “with no force”.

A worn bore produces the same effect. The seal may be new, but if the surface it runs against is oval or scored, it only contacts part of the way round. So before quoting a repair we measure the bore rather than simply fitting a seal kit — otherwise the repair comes back within a season.

When the cylinder is not at fault

Before anyone takes the cylinder off the machine, rule out the supply side. A worn piston pump loses output gradually and presents in exactly the same way: movements get slower and the machine stalls under load. A relief valve out of adjustment or stuck open dumps oil back to tank below nominal pressure. Air in the circuit gives movement that is jerky and soft.

Telling these apart takes a quarter of an hour with a gauge, and saves removing, transporting and quoting something that is sound. If the working pressure turns out to be normal and the cylinder still creeps down under load with the supply closed — only then does the cause lie in the cylinder.

Symptoms not to put off

A damp rod after extension means the sealing system has started to pass. By itself it does not stop the machine, but it predicts two things: oil contaminated with water and dust, and accelerated wear of the chrome. Leaving it for later normally turns a simple seal change into rod machining.

The second signal is a change in the sound — a hiss approaching the end of stroke, or audible oil passing while the movement is stopped. The third is rising oil consumption with no visible leak under the machine, which usually means the oil is going back through the return line past a valve.

When our service is not the answer

Reconditioning makes no sense with a cracked body or a rod bent by a side impact — restoring repeatable geometry then costs more than a new unit. It is also the wrong thing to order when the measurements showed the real cause is in the pump or a valve. You get a sound cylinder back into an unsound circuit, and the symptom stays exactly as it was.

In both situations we say so after the inspection, along with what to look for in a replacement or in the supply circuit. An honest answer costs us one job and saves the customer a second identical repair.

What happens next

If the measurements point to the cylinder, the next step is assessing the scope: the condition of the rod, the bore dimension and seals matched to the real pressure and medium. That is what we do as part of cylinder reconditioning — measured before quoting and pressure tested before handover. What it looks like on a real job is shown in two cylinders put back to work.

Częste pytania

Does a loss of force always mean a worn cylinder?

No. Just as often the cause is low pressure in the circuit — a worn pump, a relief valve out of adjustment, or air in the system. That is why the supply pressure is measured before the cylinder comes out of the machine.

Is it enough to replace the seals?

Only when the rod and the bore are within dimension and their surfaces are smooth. New seals on a scored rod wear out within weeks, so that kind of repair usually comes back.

When is a cylinder not worth repairing?

When the body is cracked or permanently deformed, restoring repeatable geometry stops being economic and buying new is the honest answer. We say so after the inspection, including when it means no job for us.

What should I prepare when sending a cylinder for assessment?

Photographs of the cylinder and of the rod at full extension, the rod diameter, the stroke, the mounting type and the working pressure of the circuit. That is enough to assess the scope of work without visiting the machine.