Skip to content

Guides · 8 September 2026

Reconditioning or a new cylinder — how to work out which pays

The cylinder can be repaired, but it is not clear whether reconditioning or buying new works out cheaper

Two corroded cylinders on a pallet, before assessing whether reconditioning pays
Two corroded cylinders on a pallet, before assessing whether reconditioning pays

Four parts of the calculation people forget

The cost of downtime

An hour of a stopped line can cost more than the whole repair. If the difference in lead time is three weeks, that settles the calculation, not the price of parts.

Fit to the machine

A reconditioned cylinder keeps its original dimensions and ports. A substitute often means altering mountings or changing hose lengths.

Availability later

On discontinued machinery, reconditioning is frequently the only route — the catalogue part simply does not exist.

The state of the rest of the circuit

A new cylinder in a circuit with contaminated oil wears out as fast as the old one did. That cost has to be added on both sides.

When reconditioning is the obvious choice

Body and mountings are sound

The damage is to seals, the rod or the bore — components that can be restored by machining.

The cylinder is non-standard

An unusual stroke, special ports or a build specific to one machine. Restoring it costs less than a one-off order.

Time is what matters

The machine is stopped and every day costs. The workshop works with what already exists instead of waiting on a delivery.

The maker is gone

No catalogue, no parts, no support. What is left is rebuilding from what arrived at the workshop.

The two routes side by side

Reconditioning A new cylinder
Cost On typical damage, a fraction of a new unit Full price plus delivery and any modifications
Lead time Working days, known after diagnosis From a week to several months on non-standard builds
Fit Original dimensions, stroke and ports Risk of differences that need mountings altered
What you can inspect Stripping it shows the condition of every component You take what arrives in the crate
When it is ruled out Cracked barrel, permanent deformation, torn-out mountings No equivalent available, machine out of production

Comparing prices alone leads to the wrong decision

The calculation usually starts and ends with two numbers: the cost of the repair and the cost of a new cylinder. That is not enough to decide well, because both numbers describe only part of the picture. They leave out lead time, fit to the machine, and what happens to production while the machine is standing.

In plants where the cylinder sits in a process line, the cost of downtime is frequently greater than the entire difference between repairing and buying. If a new unit has a lead time in weeks and the workshop returns a reconditioned one in days, the decision is made regardless of what the price comparison says.

What decides whether repair is in play at all

The state of the body and the mountings. These are load-bearing components that cannot be restored by machining without risk. A cracked tube, permanent deformation after an overload, a torn-out mounting eye — with damage like that the repair is both more expensive and less certain than a new cylinder, and that is exactly what we then propose.

Everything else can be restored. Worn seals are routine. A scored rod is ground and re-plated. A worn or oval bore is machined back. Damaged seats and guides are made new where catalogue parts no longer exist. With a sound body the calculation almost always favours reconditioning.

Fit costs more than people expect

A substitute is rarely identical. A stroke that differs by a few centimetres, a different mounting centre, a different port thread — each of those means work that was not in the calculation: altering mountings, new hoses, resetting limit switches. Sum those up and the cheaper option frequently stops being cheaper.

Reconditioning does not have that component. The cylinder comes back with the same dimensions, ports and stroke, so fitting is simply the reverse of removal. On non-standard machinery built for one particular plant, that argument carries more weight than price.

A repair guarantees nothing if the rest of the circuit stays as it was

This is worth saying plainly, because it applies equally to both options: a new cylinder fitted into a circuit with dirty, overheated oil will wear out as fast as the one just removed. Contamination circulating in the system destroys seals and scores rods regardless of whether the unit is new or reconditioned.

So while the repair is happening, check the filters, the oil condition, the working temperature and the wipers. It is a small part of the cost and it decides whether the repair lasts years or a season. When a cylinder fails prematurely, the cause almost always lies outside the cylinder.

How to run the comparison yourself

The practical order is: establish the state of the body, find out the lead time for a new unit, estimate the cost of one day of downtime, and only then compare prices against that background. In most situations the answer becomes obvious before any quotation, and the quotation merely confirms it.

If you want a quick read, photographs and basic dimensions are enough — rod diameter, bore diameter, stroke and mounting type. From those we can say whether this looks like a routine seal change or a full reconditioning, and that is already enough to set both routes against the delivery time for a new cylinder.

Częste pytania

Is a reconditioned cylinder as durable as a new one?

With full reconditioning, the components that determine durability — the rod surface, the bore and the complete sealing set — come back close to factory parameters. After that, life depends mainly on oil cleanliness and working conditions.

How quickly can I find out the price?

We give an initial estimate from photographs and dimensions, and a binding quotation after diagnosis, once the cylinder has been stripped. Only then is it clear whether grinding and chrome plating are needed or a seal change will do.

Is it worth reconditioning a cylinder that is fifteen years old?

Age on its own settles nothing. What counts is the state of the body and mountings, because they decide whether the rest can be restored. An old but structurally sound cylinder is often better material than a cheap substitute.

What if stripping it shows the repair is not worthwhile?

We say so plainly and offer to build a new cylinder instead of running an expensive repair with a short life. You are told exactly what disqualified the unit.